Wednesday, April 10, 2013

Day 10. Some Things are Scary

Book 47.
Is it wrong that, as an adult, I also find some of these things to be scary. Things like...

Waiting to jump out and say BOO! at someone is scary.

and

Thinking you're not going to be picked for either side is scary.

and especially

Playing hide-and-deek when you're it and you can't find anyone is scary.

I think a lot of my students could connect to the situations in this book. Unfortunately, I think the illustrations might turn a number of them off. Perhaps a result of production, the illustrations appear dated and faded. Not something you'd expect from a picture book published in the year 2000.

Bummer.

- Matthew

Tuesday, April 9, 2013

Day 9. Who's in the Hall?

Book 44.
I'll tell you who's in the hall and the path my brain had to follow before we finally discovered the truth.

Okay. The babysitter has left the kids in the apartment alone for a few minutes. No big deal.

Wait a second, who's knocking at the door? And if it's not the janitor, but the person says he's the janitor and that he's here to repair the sink, but the kids don't recognize the person and their babysitter says that she never told a janitor that they're sink wasn't working.... just WHO is at this door that could even remotely be appropriate for a children's picture book that isn't already on the guidance counselor's shelf and written into a thousand stranger danger and kidnapping books?!

Oh, wait. It actually is the janitor and there just seems to have been a mix-up between this apartment and another one on the bottom floor with kids that undergo near identical circumstances. 

I felt more than a little creeped out.

Yeah. That's putting it lightly.

- Matthew

Monday, April 8, 2013

Day 8. Shelf Challenge Blog Spotlight #1

While a number of us are soaking up the warm rays of Spring Break, others have been cracking spines, mending dog ears, and battling dust bunnies in the name of the 2013 Shelf Challenge.

This week's Shelf Challenge Blog Spotlight bloggers discovered new favorites, out-of-place titles, and a rising stack of books to weed. Check out their finds by clicking on the links below.

The Library Girls - Stacey (@libraryjo92) is reading the "A" books in her Everybody section, amidst an equally impressive to-read pile of her own. Don't miss what she has to say about The Pencil by Allen Ahlberg. Sounds like an awesome book!

Curtis Library Elementary - Shawna (@CurtisLibrary1) is reading through all of the "N" books in her Everybody collection and squeezes in time to share her favorite finds with all of us. I was particularly intrigued by Who Made this Cake? by Chihiro Nakagawa. 

The Merry Media Center - Misti (@MistiSikes) is spotlighting stand-out titles from the "T" authors in her Everybody section as she makes a mighty reading trek in the name of the Shelf Challenge. She arrived today at a personal favorite of mine: Tumford the Terrible by Nancy Tillman.


Blogging about your Shelf Challenge adventures? Be sure to let Matthew know by using the #ShelfChallenge hashtag to share your posts on Twitter or by emailing Matthew direct at mwinne2(at)gmail(dot)com.

Sunday, April 7, 2013

Day 7. Seven Brave Women

Book 43.
Tracing one's family lineage can reveal some interesting truths, the most memorable, of course, being those with an element of wonder or amazement. But in Seven Brave Women, Betsy Hearne reminds us that we need only look so far as the circumstances in which our ancestors lived to understand the great things each accomplished. Those who refused to abandon their beliefs, families, or passions despite society's influence demonstrate a bravery tangible to readers.

I was moved.

What surprised me most though, even now, is that I was the first to break this book's spine. It's got a copyright from 1997. Is it possible it's remained in our collection for nearly 15 years (and nearly 5 library media specialists) without ever being read by a child?

We'll have to change that.

- Matthew 

Saturday, April 6, 2013

Day 6 of 30. The Grumpalump

Book 38.
Okay, Flannel Friday friends... I know you're out there! Please tell me someone has made a flannelboard adaptation of this charming cumulative tale by Sarah Hayes.

With its rhyming wordplay and persistent playfulness, surely this is a perfect fit.

And the cast of a bear, a cat, a mole, a dove, a bull, a yak, an armadillo, and... wait for it... a gnu! Now, come on! Tell me you aren't smiling right now.

I'm not sure why I hadn't before heard of The Grumpalump (published in 1990), but I am already very much excited to share it with my PreK and Kindergarten friends in the very near future.

This is my favorite find of the 2013 Shelf Challenge by far!

- Matthew

Friday, April 5, 2013

Day 5 of 30. My Prairie Year

Book 30.
How important is it that we remember the past?

I know. I know! What a terrible question! But isn't this exactly what's running through your mind as you read through your collection and consider what to keep and what to weed?

Is it as simple as consulting circulation numbers?

This book hasn't been checked out in nearly 10 years, therefore it needs to be weeded.

Can you reason weeding the title based on its publication year?

This book was published in 1986 and is nearly two decades older than our oldest students.

Can format be blamed?

This book's pencil illustrations are moving and evocative, but the bulky paragraphs would turn off any of our readers.

It doesn't seem fair. My Prairie Year, written from the journal entries of Elenore Plaisted, a successful children's book illustrator, at the age of nine in 1889, is a perfectly preserved slice of history. But it's in it's very DNA that it loses it's modern audience. It doesn't match the curriculum. It's of an experience to which none of our students could relate. It just doesn't fit.

And I'm having a very hard time coming to terms with that.

- Matthew

Thursday, April 4, 2013

Day 4 of 30. Princess Hyacinth

Book 23.
What is it about princess stories that keeps them feeling new? Perhaps it's subtle twists to the familiar story, like in Princess Hyacinth (the Surprising tale of a Girl who Floated). Here we have a princess who, like most, seems bored of her royal upbringings. She longs to feel freedom from the burdens her life has bestowed upon her (in this case, the burdens being literal to keep her from floating off). The story's not told with a great deal of whit, nor does it need to be. You're charmed because it's charming.

Plain and simple.

- Matthew

LinkWithin

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...